I am saying that I like retail better...
Slaven I have played private servers for at least 2 or 3 years...
Do you know what it is like to go to a server, and have every single mob scripted? To have player location in a group working? To have ALL BGs working and filled 24/7? To have constant pvp? Have you ever experience Brewfest? The REAL Darkmoon Faire? Have you ever seen every quest working as they are supposed to?
This list is endless, and if you ask me that question, the answer is yes.